Bell Bean
Growing Period | Type | Annual or Perennial | Drought Tolerance | Salinity Tolerance |
---|---|---|---|---|
Cool Season | Legume | Annual | Intolerant | Low |
Common Name
Scientific Name
Cultivar
Small-seeded varieties of faba beans are called bell beans (Miller, 1988). Varieties include 'Windsor,' 'Longpod,' 'Dwarf Fan,' 'Julienne,' 'Lorraine,' 'Black Spanish,' 'Mazagan,' 'Piccardy,' and 'Winter' (Duke, 1981). Varieties of bell beans with the highest biomass production are 'Ackerperle,' 'Herz Freya,' 'Aladin,' and 'Minnesota Horsebean' (Brinton, 1989).
Stutzel and Aufhammer (1991) observed that the determinate variety 'Herz Freya' rarely produced side shoots even at low plant densities, whereas the indeterminate 'Ticol' produced side shoots, mainly from the basal nodes.
The variety that has often been sold in California is 'Diana.'
Seed Description
Seedling Description
Mature Plant Description
Bell bean is a coarse, erect, glabrous, very leafy annual, 5 to 20 dm. high; leaves fleshy, glaucous, turning black in drying, without tendrils; leaflets 2 to 6, oval, 4 to 10 cm. long, 1 to 3 cm. wide, obtuse, apiculate; stipules large, semisagittate, entire or shallowly dentate; racemes 2- to 4- flowered, very short-peduncled; flowers large (2 to 3 cm. long), white blotched with deep maroon or blackish violet; pods large (8 to 20 cm. long, 1 to 3 cm. wide), plump 2- to 4- seeded (Hermann, 1960). Madson (1951) described the plant as coarse, erect, and stemmy, with a large taproot, and large leaflets. The flower is white with a black spot on each wing and is borne in sessile axillary racemes. Seeds are large. Faba bean (cv 'Fiord') at maturity contained 50% of total dry matter and 78% (90 kg/ha) of total nitrogen in the seed, 30 kg/ha in the stubble, and 6-8% of the N fixed (less than 15 kg N/ha) in the root system (Herdina and Silsbury, 1990).
Figier (1968) distinguished 3 types of nectary cells in the stipular extrafloral nectaries: 1) cellules de la couche basale; 2) cellules du trichome; and 3) cellules compagnes. Acid phosphatase enzyme was detected in and around the plasmalemma, suggesting the transplant of sugar. Figier (1971) further examined the fine structure of these nectaries, discerning two types of cells, those concerned with excretion and those involved in transit processes between phloem and trichome.
Temperature
Geographic Range
Water
Bell bean tolerates a wide variety of drainage conditions (Peaceful Valley, 1988) but will not tolerate drought (Duke, 1981; Pears et al., 1989; Husain et al., (1990), which at flowering or pod formation can cause severe reduction of seed yields (Koscielniak et al., 1989). In northern Germany, droughts during May and June cause low pod set of spring-sown faba bean. Bell bean is notorious for unstable yields, which appear in part due to its susceptibility to drought (Herzog, 1989). Bell bean can be grown from 23-209 cm of precipitation (mean of 95 cases = 12.1) (Duke, 1981). Husain et al. (1990) found that roots of drought-stressed faba bean (cv 'Maris Bead') extended as far as 0.85 m in depth. Average rooting depth was 0.70 m for drought-stressed and 0.52 m for irrigated plants. As drought stress increases, faba bean shows the following responses: (1) rate of shoot growth declines; (2) leaf area expansion decreases slightly; (3) root growth increases; (4) smaller leaves are produced; (5) leaves are shed; (6) shoot dry matter decreases. It has been thought that faba bean is most sensitive to drought stress during flowering because root growth ceases at this point for well-irrigated plants. This is not the case with drought-stressed plants, i.e., root growth can continue. Thus, sensitivity to drought is more or less uniform throughout the development of the plant. Reid (1990), based on simulation modeling, suggests that increased root growth was the most effective adaptation by which faba bean copes with drought stress, at least until 21 days from maturity. Breeding programs should probably emphasize the ability of plants to respond in this fashion. Deep tillage may also be beneficial in removing impediments to deep rooting.
Grashoff and Verkerke (1991) evaluated six cultivars of bell beans, detailing the effect of mild water shortage from flowering on. These workers showed that reduced turgor under these conditions promotes reproductive growth and reduces vegetative growth. Drought stress leads to lack of osmotic adjustment to maintain expansive growth.
Nutrients
P and K are applied before or at seeding (Duke, 1981).
Like all legumes, bell beans will also respond well to sulfur especially in high rainfall areas.
Soil pH
Bell bean has been said to tolerate basic to acidic soils (Munoz & Graves, 1988), ranging from pH of 4.5-8.3 (mean of 87 cases, 6.6) (Duke, 1981), and the crop is grown without liming throughout the U.S. (Duke, 1981). However, nodulation may be delayed under acid conditions (Hartmann and Aldag, 1989). Faba bean (cv 'Herz Freya') showed delayed nodulation where soil pH was low, whereas white lupin (cv 'Eldo') showed no decrease in N-fixation (Hartmann and Aldag, 1989).
In a pot experiment, Schubert et al. (1990) observed that at pH 4, chloride exclusion was disabled, and absorbtion of all other major ions decreased. ATPase activity necessitates release of protons. This is believed to be interfered with under low pH (i.e., high proton concentrations).
Schubert et al. (1990) conducted two pot and two water culture experiments on effects of low pH and soil buffering capacity, bell bean proton (H+) release, growth, and ionic content. Based on results of some of the experiments, these authors speculated that bell bean sensitivity to increasing soil acidity may be related to an inability to exclude chloride (Cl-) ion at low pH of soil solution.
Soil Type
Bell bean tolerates a wide variety of soils (Peaceful Valley, 1988), doing well in loam to clay soils (Madson, 1951; Munoz & Graves, 1988), and best in well drained, heavy silt or clay loams with large quantities of humus and calcium. Pears et al. (1989) say that it does best on heavy soils, whereas Duke (1981) maintains that it performs best on rich loam soils. This species can be grown successfully on light soil with ample moisture and lime (McLeod, 1982). According to Miller (1988), it can be useful on heavy soils, because residue persists after being disked in.
Bell beans will tolerate heavy soils better than most vetch and peas. It is often planted on new laser-leveled adope rice fields subjected to flooding. When submerged for 5-7 days bell beans will die.
Shade Tolerance
Salinity Tolerance
Herbicide Sensitivity
In NSW Australia, Lemerke and Hinkley (1991) observed that bell bean tolerated glyphosate (Round-Up) if application occurred 11 weeks after sowing or later.
Life Cycle
Seeding Rate
Seeding Depth
Seeding Method
Seeding Dates
Inoculation
Seed Cost
Days to Flowering
Days to Maturity
Seed Production
Growth Habit
Maximum Height
Root System
Like most legumes, bell bean is taprooted (Miller, 1988) and is mentioned as having a strong root system (Peaceful Valley, 1988). Nevertheless, it is a drought-intolerant plant (Husain et al., 1990). Roots of drought-stressed faba bean (cv 'Maris Bead') extended as far as 0.85 m in depth. Average rooting depth was 0.70 m for drought-stressed and 0.52 m for irrigated plants. As drought stress increases, faba bean shows the following responses: (1) rate of shoot height increase declines; (2) leaf area expansion decreases slightly; (3) root growth increases; (4) smaller leaves are produced; (5) leaves are shed; (6) shoot dry matter decreases. It has been thought that faba bean is most sensitive to drought stress during flowering because root growth ceases at this point for well-irrigated plants. This is not the case with drought-stressed plants, i.e., root growth can continue. Thus, sensitivity to drought is more or less uniform throughout the development of the plant (Husain et al., 1990).
Simulation modeling suggests that increased root growth was the most effective adaptation by which faba bean copes with drought stress at least until 21 days from maturity. Breeding programs should probably emphasize the ability of plants to respond this way. Deep tillage may also be beneficial in removing impediments to deep rooting (Reid, 1990).
From a depth of 60-90 cm in the soil stratum, white lupin (cv 'Eldo') root mass was 6 times that of faba bean (cv 'Herz Freya'). Overall root mass was 125 g/square meter for stands of white lupin and 86 g/square meter for faba bean (Hartmann and Aldag, 1989).
Faba bean (cv Fiord) at maturity contained 50% of total dry matter and 78% (90 kg/ha) of total nitrogen in the seed, 30 kg/ha in the stubble, and 6-8% of the N fixed (less than 15 kg N/ha) in the root system (Herdina and Silsbury, 1990).
Establishment
Maintenance
Mowing
In general, bell bean does not respond favorably to mowing or grazing (Munoz & Graves, 1988). It can tolerate some high mowing for frost control (Peaceful Valley, 1988) but will not withstand close mowing (Bugg, pers. comm.). Pears et al. (1989) says that it can be cut down once and left to regrow.
Filik et al. (1996) stated taht detopping cv 'Nadwislanski' reduced nodule initiation, reduced aging of plants, and delayed pod shed.
Incorporation
Harvesting
Equipment
Uses
Mixtures
Biomass
N Contribution
Estimated amount of N fixed may range from 22.7-90.7 kg/acre (50-200 lb), but bell bean is regarded as a low nitrogen fixer in southern California (Munoz & Graves, 1988). In six weeks of growth, bell bean may fix up to 45.4 kg/acre (100 lb) (McLeod, 1982) and a total of up to 68.0 kg/acre (150 lb) on fertile soils (Peaceful Valley, 1988). Bell bean has a lower N content in above-ground biomass than most other legume cover crops. Less than 45.4 kg N/ac (100 lb) was fixed by late March in 1987 in an experiment in Davis (Stivers & Shennan, 1991). At plowdown, available N from bell bean can be estimated by multiplying harvested fresh weight of cover crop from a sixteen square feet (4 x 4 ft) sample plot by 10 (to estimate lbs of N/acre) (Miller et al., 1989).
Cv 'Wieselburger' at physiological maturity (126 days after planting) contained 209 kg N/ha, 79% (165 kg N/ha) of which came from fixation. After the mid-podfilling stage, N-fixation dropped to nearly nothing. If pods and and seeds were removed, faba bean residue would contribute approximately 27 kg/ha of N to the soil (Zapata et al.,1987).
Cv 'Fiord' began fixing nitrogen 53 days after sowing and accumulated 80% of its fixed nitrogen during grain filling; at maturity, it contained 50% of total dry matter and 78% (90 kg/ha) of total nitrogen in the seed, 30 kg/ha in the stubble, and 6-8% of the N fixed (less than 15 kg N/ha) in the root system (Herdina and Silsbury, 1990).
For cv 'Herz Freya,' N gain after seed harvest was 8 g/m2. Nitrogen fixation rates at different locations were approximately as follows during 1986: 60, 310, 180, 170, and 190 kg/ha2 (Hartmann and Aldag, 1989).
A literature review indicates that N-fixation by pea reaches a maximum before or at flowering and drops during pod formation, whereas in faba bean substantial fixation continues up to plant maturity (Buttery and Gibson, 1990). Bell bean cv 'Herz Freya' showed delayed nodulation where soil pH was low, whereas white lupin (cv 'Eldo') showed no decrease in N-fixation (Hartmann and Aldag, 1989). In Germany, winter crops of rape, barley, and Welsh ryegrass respectively accumulated in their above-ground structures 52.1, 36.2, and 22.9 kg N/ha following bell bean (cv 'Alfred') (Raderschall and Gebhardt, 1990). In an experiment on rotational cash crops ("break crops") for wheat farmers, fertilizer N requirements were increased by 10 kg/ha following winter oat, decreased by 30 kg/ha following winter rape, winter peas, spring faba beans, or cultivated fallow, and decreased by 40 kg/ha following spring peas (McEwen et al., 1989).
In Davis, Stivers and Shennan (1991) found that bell bean produced 80 lb N/ac. by March 28. This was less than for field pea (150, 3.5% N) or woolypod vetch (230, 3.6% N).
Effects on Water
Effects on Livestock
Effects on Workers
Pest Effects, Insects
Peaceful Valley (1988) suggested that beneficial insects do well on the numerous blossoms, but extrafloral nectaries appearing as dark spots on the stipules are probably more important (Bugg, pers. comm.). These nectaries occur from early vegetative growth through late pod filling. From mid September through late October, sixty specimens of Ichneumonidae (Hymenoptera), representing 20 species and 4 subfamilies, were observed feeding at the extrafloral nectaries (cv 'Ipro'). Of the ichneumonids collected, 3 were known parasites of lepidopterous pests of agriculture, 2 of forest Lepidoptera, and three of both agricultural and forest Lepidoptera (Bugg et al., 1989). Trujillo-Arriaga and Altieri (1990) grew faba bean in tricultures with maize and squash. Faba bean provided extrafloral nectar that was fed upon by the lady beetles Hippodamia convergens and H. koebelei. This probably contributed to the observed greater densities of these lady beetles, the higher yield of maize, and the elevated total output per unit area (land equivalent ratio=2.89) in the tricultures. Densities of lady beetles appeared relatively low in all treatments, and inferential statistics were not presented.
Bell bean is regarded as more susceptible to aphid infestations than the vetches (Miller, 1988); in particular, it is attacked by bean aphid (Aphis fabae L.) which seldom affects its use as a cover crop but often interferes with the production of seed (Madson, 1951). Bugg and Ellis (1989) reported that a May-planted crop of faba bean was heavily infested by bean aphid, which apparently damaged the crop. Bean aphid was tended by Formica spp. ants, which were observed repelling some lady beetles. Nonetheless, faba bean sustained relatively high densities of aphidophaga (mainly lady beetles) during several weeks in late June. Thereafter, bean aphid densities plummeted during an outbreak by an unidentified entomogenous fungus, which occurred following several days of wet weather.
Pruter and Zebitz (1991) reported experiments on cvs 'Diana' and 'Bolero', which are respectively susceptible and partially resistant to bean aphid. (Aphis fabae). Bean aphid damaged both varieties, and reduced root dry weight, shoot dry weight, leaf area, and mean relative growth rate more than did broad bean rust pathogen (Uromyces viciae faba). Bean aphid reduction of all parameters mentioned was greater for the susceptible variety 'Diana'.
Grafton-Cardwell et al. (unpublished manuscript) found that pollen of bell bean, 'Austrian Winter' field pea, and New Zealand white clover sustained longevity and fecundity of the predatory mite Euseius tularensis (Acari: Phytoseiidae) as well as the standard diet of iceplant pollen. By contrast, reduced fecundity was observed for common vetch, woollypod vetch, and crimson clover, and E. tularensis did not survive more than one generation when fed pollen of rose clover or red clover. Inoculation with E. tularensis in early spring led to build-up of the mite by late spring in a cover crop of bell bean, field pea, and woollypod vetch. Most of the mites were found on the bell bean component of the mix. When the cover crop was mowed and the mowings placed in young citrus trees, significantly increased densities of the predatory mite were observed on the citrus foliage.
Pest Effects, Nematodes
Pest Effects, Diseases
Faba bean is not susceptible to Sclerotinia minor (Koike et al., 1996).
Pruter and Zebitz (1991) reported experiments on cvs 'Diana' and 'Bolero', which are respectively susceptible and partial resistance to bean aphid. (Aphis fabae). Bean aphid damaged both varieties, and reduced root dry weight, shoot dry weight, leaf area, and mean relative growth rate more than did broad bean rust pathogen (Uromyces viciae faba). Bean aphid reduction of all parameters mentioned was greater for the susceptible variety 'Diana'.
Bell beans, especially in California, are frequently attacked by bacterial blast. It forms black lesions in cold damp weather especially on the stems. Observations in a Sonoma County field for forage production showed a 30% loss of the stand due to this disease.